Some links are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you choose to follow them—at no extra cost to you. It helps keep Growls & Grimm running.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Review of The Legend of Syn by Katie Gaskin
Epic Fantasy | Romantic Fantasy | Slow Burn
Book 1 of 4 Legend of Syn Series
“Nearly twice as tall as any man near him, this king had skin like a moonless night. “
When Emmie’s father suggests an adventure across the sea, she can’t wait to go on this new adventure. Little does she know how much her life will change. Their ship wrecks in a foreign land, captured by guards, and losing her father while trying to save him, turns Emmie’s world upside down. When she sees The God of Change, she doesn’t realize how much more her life is going to change, now part of a harem she has to navigate loss, a new land, and the unending want return to the life she knew.
Should You Read The Legend of Syn?
If you enjoy character-driven fantasy that focuses heavily on emotional processing, personal growth, and immersive world-building, this book may be a good fit.
The world is dominated by God’s, guiding mortals through different phased of life and the world order. There is a strong old world charm that I find is classic in most fantasy books. This allows the reader to easily envision the world in the way the author intends it. The attention to small details in The Legend of Syn lends to the world building and also offers more insight into how the characters think and respond.
While the premise suggests a romance centered around a powerful and transformative God of Change, much of the story focuses on Emmie’s adjustment to her circumstances, resulting in a slower and more introspective reading experience than I expected. There are moment’s where you can see the dynamics changing between the characters, this story is more from Emmie’s point of view so it is based on her interpretation.
There is tension in this book and it comes more from Emmie finding her footing in her new reality than the relationship between her, Ashay, and the other characters.. The way she works through not only her grief for her old life but her current circumstances, constant change and negotiation, her tension is palatable through the entire story.
The premise drew me in immediately: a morally gray God of Change, a grieving heroine, and a world shaped by divine influence. It felt like the perfect setup for an epic fantasy romance filled with transformation, tension, and complicated relationships.
Instead, I found the story much more focused on Emmie’s emotional processing and adjustment to her circumstances than on the romance or the larger conflicts suggested by the premise. While I appreciated the attention given to her grief and personal growth, the repetitive internal monologue often slowed the pacing and made the story feel longer than it needed to be.
I was also hoping for more development between Emmie and Ashay. Because so much of the story hinges on their relationship, I struggled to fully invest in the romance when many of their interactions felt distant or underdeveloped. By the end, I found myself far more interested in the supporting cast, the gods, and the wider world than the central relationship itself.
Readers who enjoy highly introspective fantasy with a strong focus on emotional healing and personal growth may have a very different experience than I did. However, if you’re picking this up primarily for the romance, morally gray love interest, or slow-burn tension, it’s worth knowing that those elements take a back seat to Emmie’s internal journey for much of the story.
Readers who enjoy immersive world building and character-focused stories centered on emotional growth may find more to appreciate here than I did.
If this story stayed with you, these reads belong on your shelf → Fantasies that Refuse Clear Sides
Track your reading journey here → Summer TBR Tracker
The Letter
A seasonal note from Growls & Grimm
Join the letter
If you’re building your next reading stack, you can follow along with everything I’m reading (and what’s actually worth it) here:
→ Goodreads + StoryGraph
And if you want to wander the shelves a little longer, the seasonal reading rooms and themed stacks live here:
→ Pinterest