Some links are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you choose to follow them—at no extra cost to you. It helps keep Growls & Grimm running.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
If you loved these fantasy favorites, read these next because you don’t always need something completely new.
Sometimes, the best next read isn’t a departure, it’s a continuation. A familiar feeling, a similar atmosphere, a story that fits beside something you already loved instead of trying to replace it.
If you’ve found yourself wanting more of a certain kind of magic, these pairings are built to meet you there, no searching required.
If You Loved These Fantasy Favorites Book List
Cozy Witchy Energy
If you loved:
- The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches
Read next:
- The Ex Hex by Glen Graves
If what pulled you in was the approachable magic, the sense of belonging, and the feeling that the world could be softened just a little, this is a natural next step.
It carries that same ease, with a slightly more playful tone, giving you more witchy charm without losing the comfort.
The Ex Hex by Glen Graves can be found on Books-A-Million and Amazon
Forest Magic / Atmospheric Fantasy
If you loved:
- Uprooted
Read next:
- For the Throne by Hannah Whitten
Dark woods, quiet tension, and magic that feels rooted rather than explosive—this pairing leans into atmosphere over spectacle.
If you’re drawn to stories where the setting feels just as alive as the characters, this next read keeps you firmly in that space.
For the Throne by Hannah Whitten can be found on Books-A-Million and Amazon
Soft, Character-Driven Fantasy
If you loved:
- The House in the Cerulean Sea
Read next:
- In the Lives of Puppets by T.J. Klune
Some stories stay with you because of how they feel, not just what happens.
This pairing keeps that emotional core intact, character-first storytelling, quiet humor, and connections that build naturally over time. Different world, same sense of heart.
In the Lives of Puppets by T.J. Klune can be found on Books-A-Million and Amazon
Epic but Grounded Fantasy
If you loved:
- The Bear and the Nightingale
Read next:
- Spinning Silver by Naomi Novik
For those who want something expansive without losing that grounded, folklore-inspired feeling, this pairing delivers.
Both stories draw from myth and tradition, weaving something larger while still feeling rooted and intentional, never overwhelming, always immersive.
Spinning Silver by Naomi Novik can be found on Books-A-Million and Amazon
Why This Works
Not every next read needs to be a leap.
Sometimes, the best stories come from staying close to what already works, following the same threads, the same atmosphere, the same quiet pull that made you fall into a story in the first place.
These pairings aren’t about discovery for the sake of it.
They’re about continuation.
Find Your Next Without Starting Over
If you:
- want more of what you already love
- prefer familiar tones over constant novelty
- enjoy settling into a reading rhythm instead of chasing the next big thing
then this kind of list makes it easy to keep going without losing your place.
Stay With What Works
You don’t need to reinvent your reading habits every month.
Sometimes, the best choice is to stay with what you know and let the next story feel just as right as the last.
Explore more books in this theme: If You Loved These Fantasy Favorites
Books-A-Million | Amazon | Book Outlet
Turn this list into your next reading ritual → Spring T.B.R. Tracker
Explore more curated reading rooms → Library
Want more stories to haunt your shelves? Visit Books & Bookish or Book list for curated reads worth a candlelit night. Or visit the Library for more books I’ve read.