Review Just Like the Other Girls
Psychological Thriller | Murder Thriller | Suspense
This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Every purchase helps keep the Growls & Grimm library lantern glowing—thank you for supporting this cozy corner of the shadows.
There are times when things are never as clear as they seem. When family secrets, grief, and loss collide, they can pull you down paths you never meant to take, and remind you that not everything that glitters is gold.
When Una’s mother dies, and her best friend Courtney begins spending more time with her boyfriend than at home, Una decides it’s time for a change. She takes a new job as an in-home caregiver in a house that looks like something out of a dream, hoping for a fresh start. Almost immediately, she feels the tension, first between herself and Kathryn, and then between Kathryn and her mother, Elspeth, the woman Una has been hired to care for. When Kathryn isn’t around, the relationship between Una and Elspeth begins to grow, but when all three women are together, the atmosphere is thick with unease. And once Una learns that the two caregivers before her have died, she starts to question whether this job was ever a good idea.
The story is driven by shifting relationships and a constant sense of uncertainty. There are plenty of twists and turns, and it’s never entirely clear who—or what—is the real threat. Douglas plays with that ambiguity throughout the book, and it works well for the mystery she’s building. The tension carries the narrative forward, and while the truth doesn’t fully reveal itself until the end, the conclusion does a satisfying job of tying everything together without relying on cliffhangers.
One of the book’s strengths is how vividly it’s written. The house, the setting, and the characters are easy to picture, from the sweeping scenery to small, telling details. In another story, that level of description might feel overwhelming, but here it adds to the atmosphere and makes the unease feel more immersive.
The suspense is what really holds this book together. It’s difficult to predict where the story is going, and that uncertainty is what makes it such a compelling read. The tension feels purposeful rather than gimmicky, and by the end, I was invested enough to know I’d happily read more from this author.
Should You Read Just Like the Other Girls?
If you enjoy psychological thrillers, slow-burn suspense, and stories driven by uneasy relationships and atmosphere, this is a strong pick. This book is best for readers who like tension that builds through character dynamics and setting rather than fast-paced action or constant shock twists.
Read this if you like:
- Domestic or psychological thrillers
- Stories where the house and setting feel like part of the mystery
- Slow-building tension and layered character relationships
You might want to skip this if:
- You prefer very fast-paced, action-heavy thrillers
- You want clear answers and straightforward villains early on
Overall, Just Like the Other Girls is a tense, atmospheric read that keeps you guessing and leans heavily on mood, relationships, and uncertainty rather than spectacle. If you like your thrillers filled with suspense, mystery, and simmering tension between characters, this one is worth picking up.
Track your reading journey here → T.B.R. Tracker
Want more stories to haunt your shelves? Visit Books & Bookish for curated reads worth a candlelit night. Or visit the Library for more books I’ve read.